scmo_banner_news.jpg


Church responds to Scottish executives consultation on 'Religious Hatred'.
(NB: The full text of the response is reproduced below.)

The Catholic Bishops of Scotland have today responded to the Scottish Executive's consultation on 'Religious Hatred' in a three page submission, they comment; "(In responding) we wish to express our firm commitment, and that of the Catholic community, in striving to foster a culture in Scotland which recognises the equal dignity of all persons"

They add however;

" A historical understanding of prejudice and religious hatred,is however a fundamental pre-requisite to progress, legislation which forms the constitution of the United Kingdom has traditionally discriminated against Catholics; e.g. the Act of Settlement and Bill of Rights. Once the State concedes that discrimination against a particular group (in this case Catholics) is acceptable, it is difficult to see how it can regain the moral authority needed to criticise religious hatred and intolerance wherever it is found." The submission concludes: "it is our view that religious tolerance should be pursued by fully promoting religious freedom. This right is an essential requirement of the dignity of every person and necessary for the personal fulfilment of each individual and as such is necessary for peaceful human co-existence. "

The Catholic Church's Parliamentary Officer, John Deighan said: "Religious freedom must be the platform on which tolerance and harmony in our society is based. We believe that our Catholic schools uphold and promote the principles of tolerance, harmony and respect for diversity in Scottish society."

Mr Deighan added;"The Catholic Bishops in this response aim to make a positive contribution which they hope will provide a foundation on which a cosiety free from religious intolerance can be built. Meanwhile the Church stands ready to assist the Scottish Executive and others in working towards this goal."

 


FULL TEXT OF RESPONSE
Response by the Bishops' Conference of Scotland to Tackling Religious Hatred' 10th March 2003

Introduction

The Catholic Bishops' Conference of Scotland is pleased to take this opportunity to make comment on the recommendations which have been made by the Cross- Party Working Group on Religious Hatred. In doing so we wish to express our firm commitment, and that of the Catholic community, in striving to foster a culture in Scotland which recognises the equal dignity of all persons. We are firmly of the view that faith and religion have an essential role to play in the building of a harmonious society. The divisions and hatred which threaten to impoverish our society by distorting or suppressing the authentic spirit of religion must be overcome and we welcome the Scottish Executive's willingness to face up to this issue.

Response to Recommendations

Recommendation 1
In order to have a means of monitoring and evaluating the changing prevalence of crime motivated by religious hatred it would be beneficial to have some means of recording offences with such a factor, the recommendation does not raise any difficulty in the eyes of the Church. It would seem sensible that the Lord Advocate issue guidelines to adapt to particular concerns when necessary. One point briefly mentioned in the report does raise slight concern. Paragraph 2.11 raises the point that people making the sign of the cross' could in some cases be committing a breach of the peace in common law. Whilst we deeply regret that anyone would misuse what is a prayer which is so greatly revered in the Catholic faith, we believe the concept that it could be used to alarm, upset or provoke' others so as to be a criminal offence, a novel reading of common law which is more likely to re-enforce sectarianism. The situation where the sign of the cross' would be banned would seem to be a victory for those who are intolerant of any manifestation of the Catholic faith.

Recommendation 2
In highlighting the need to combat religious intolerance it is reasonable to take measures which ensure that such elements of crimes are not hidden and therefore seemingly go unpunished and, or unrecorded. The recommendation, in this context, therefore seems reasonable.

Recommendation 3
For the reasons stated above this measure would seem also to be a crucial element of measuring the level and nature of crime motivated by religious hatred.

Recommendation 4
The situation in which society finds itself today is one where many of the twists and turns of history which created a climate of enmity between
religions have been largely forgotten. Often only a vague and irrational dislike of other denominations or faiths remains as the visible face of
religious hatred. A historical understanding of prejudice and religious hatred, once evident even in employment, is however a fundamental pre-requisite to progress. The path of history is such that legislation which forms the constitution of the United Kingdom has traditionally discriminated against Catholics; e.g. the Act of Settlement and Bill of Rights. Once the State concedes that discrimination against a particular group (in this case Catholics) is acceptable, it is difficult to see how it can regain the moral authority needed to criticise religious hatred and intolerance wherever it is found.

Equally important is an understanding of the current dynamics of community life which create the conditions that lead to division, distrust and bigotry. Religious hatred can be overcome and it is hoped that a full analysis of the issues, wider than the football-dominated focus which has prevailed to date, will be undertaken.

Recommendation 5 - 11
Where sectarianism is a problem in the support of some teams it should be expected that clubs take reasonable steps to eradicate the problem. This effort will be more effective if carried out in conjunction with interested parties and the appropriate local authorities. The measures contained in recommendations 5 to 11 therefore provide a suitable basis for directing efforts to eradicate the problems which arise in relation to football matches. It is our opinion that a wider consideration of football related problems is required. There are problems of intimidation and possible violence for those who encounter travelling fans on trains, ferries and public transport in general, and may be identified as belonging to "the other side". It is also important that in focussing on the Old Firm', evidence of religious hatred connected with other football teams is not ignored.

Recommendation 12
Education is a vital element in overcoming the resentment of those from different communities but on its own does not produce people free of resentment and hatred. The task of creating a harmonious society is always one requiring considerable effort, formation is as necessary as information. In responding to the frictions which arise in society because of the different constituent ethnic or religious communities attempts to eradicate differences are counterproductive and often unjust; rather it is our view that religious tolerance should be pursued by fully promoting religious freedom. This right is an essential requirement of the dignity of every person and necessary for the personal fulfilment of each individual and as such is necessary for peaceful human co-existence. In recognising that religious intolerance is evident in Scotland we propose the following principles as the foundation of understanding and practising religious
tolerance:

  1. The right to religious freedom is grounded in respect for human dignity.
  2. Individuals should not be forced to act in a manner contrary to their religious beliefs, nor should they be restrained from acting in accordance with their religious beliefs.
  3. Religious bodies have a right to manifest and teach the social relevance of their religious beliefs.
  4. Religious bodies have a right to establish and maintain corporate institutions and services and conduct them in accordance with their religious beliefs and values.
  5. Because the right to religious freedom is exercised within society, it ought to be subject to the laws which ordinarily safeguard justice and civil order.
  6. Civil authorities do not have the right to command or inhibit acts of religion which are outside their proper competence.

Promoting such principles contributes to the recognition of the dignity of each individual, which is a necessary condition for creating a free and just society. The Catholic Community, not least through Catholic schooling, endeavours to provide formation rooted in these most fundamental values thus making a valuable contribution not just to Scottish education but also to the social life of our nation.


ENDS

Contact:  
John Deighan
Catholic Parliamentary Office
5 St. Vincent Place
GLASGOW
G1 2DH
Tel.: 0141 222 2182
Mob.: 07930 405 313

Peter Kearney
Catholic Media Office
0141 221 1168
pk@scmo.org

Subscribe to Updates

Subscribe to:
Like   Back to Top   Seen 113 times   Liked 0 times

Subscribe to Updates

If you enjoyed this, why not subscribe to free email updates ?

Subscribe to News updates

Enter your email address to be notified of new posts:

Subscribe to:

Alternatively, you can subscribe via RSS

‹ Return to News

We never share or sell your email address to anyone.

I've already subscribed / don't show me this again

Recent Posts

Pax Christi Scotland launches with inaugural conference in Glasgow

| 3 days ago | Blogging

Wednesday 14 November     Pax Christi Scotland, a newly-formed peace project, will officially launch later this month (23-25 November) with its inaugural conference at the Conforti Centre in Coatbridge, hosted and funded by the Xaverian Missionaries.       Its mission is to promote peace in the family, the school, the parish, and the wider community. The project will fall under the guiding principles of Pax Christi International (the Peace of Christ) a global, Gospel-based faith movement, whose mission is to create a world where people can live in peace, without fear of violence in any form.      Key speakers at the event include Liz Dornan of the Scottish Catholic Education Service, who will address the issue of promoting an environment of peace in our schools.     Marian Pallister, member of the Pax Christi Scotland steering group said:      “Pope Francis has encouraged us to create a society in which nonviolence pervades all aspects of our lives. It is no longer enough to demonstrate against nuclear weapons and campaign against arms sales. We must start at grass roots level to instil an ethos of nonviolence in the home, the playground, and the parish. If we can be at peace with our physical neighbour, it becomes easier to reach out in peace and love to the ‘neighbours’ Christ suggests - the migrant, the refugee, the stranger.     “Pax Christi Scotland aims to nurture nonviolence at every level.”     ENDS     Peter Kearney Director Catholic Media Office 5 St. Vincent Place Glasgow G1 2DH 0141 221 1168 07968 122291 pk@scmo.org www.scmo.org     Note to Editors:   For further information about Pax Christi Scotland contact Marian Pallister, marian.pallister@zen.co.uk, or 07768 731145     If you would like to attend the conference please contact Anna at Conforti, anna@confortiinstitute.org. Registration will be from 5pm on the Friday and all meals from Friday supper to Sunday lunch are included.  ...

Scottish Bishops celebrate centenary of Catholic Education at Edinburgh Castle

| 4 days ago | Blogging

Tuesday 13 November 2018     Scotland’s Deputy First Minister, John Swinney will celebrate the centenary of the 1918 Education Act together with the Catholic bishops of Scotland tomorrow evening (Wednesday 14thof November) at a reception in Edinburgh Castle.     The event marks the beginning of the week that leads up to the date the Act was signed, bringing Catholic schools into the state sector, 21stNovember 1918, and is the culmination of a year of special celebration and reflection.     Archbishop Philip Tartaglia, President of the Scottish Catholic Education Commission said:     “The Scottish Government’s support for Catholic schools is greatly appreciated, I welcome the fact that events like this recognise the contribution which Catholic schools make to education in Scotland and to wider Scottish society.”     Barbara Coupar, Director of the Scottish Catholic Education Service, said:     “We are delighted that members of the Scottish Catholic Education Community have been invited, along with representatives of the other Denominational bodies that have schools within Scotland (Episcopalian and Jewish communities), to celebrate this historic occasion.      “It is fitting that the Deputy First Minister should mark the centenary of the 1918 Act, an Act which saw Scotland move ahead of other countries in supporting the right of parents to educate their children according to their faith, as denominational schools are yet another area within education where Scotland remains sector leading.       “This event shows the ongoing partnership between the Government and the Church and highlights the support that denominational education has from our elected members.  In particular, we are honoured that the Papal Nuncio will be attending as Mr Swinney’s guest.”     Deputy First Minister John Swinney added:     “I am delighted to celebrate that, for 100 years now, Catholic schools have been part of the fabric of the Scottish education system.     “The 1918 Education Act recognised the significant contribution that faith-based schools make to Scotland and the Scottish Government maintains that outlook today.     “Every child in Scotland should have an equal chance to fulfil their potential. We welcome the continued contribution of Catholic schools in helping to achieve that ambition by fostering an environment where children can follow their faith, learn successfully and become confident individuals.”     ENDS     Peter Kearney Director Catholic Media Office 5 St. Vincent Place Glasgow G1 2DH 0141 221 1168 07968 122291 pk@scmo.org www.scmo.org     Notes to Editors:     Images will be available from the Scottish Catholic Media Office: mail@scmo.org   Two Catholic secondary schools will provide musical entertainment; Notre Dame High School, Greenock and St Ambrose, Coatbridge. A pupil from St Benedict’s High School, Linwood – Evonne Jeffrey will pipe guests in to the great hall.   The guests from the Catholic Church include: the eight bishops of Scotland, the nominated Church Representatives on Local Authority Education Committees, Head Teachers and pupils from each of the eight Scottish Catholic dioceses. ...

Scottish bishops elect new office bearers

| 07th November 2018 | Blogging

Wednesday 7 November     At their meeting on Wednesday 7 November 2018, the members of the Bishops’ Conference of Scotland elected the following office bearers, who will serve a term of three years:     President: Bishop Hugh GilbertVice President: Bishop John KeenanEpiscopal Secretary: Bishop Brian McGee     Commenting on his election, Bishop Gilbert said;      “I am honoured to have been chosen as President of the Bishops’ Conference and thank the bishops for the trust they have placed in me. I accept the mandate given to me aware of the challenges the church faces, while conscious of the great treasures she holds and continues to offer as a point of reference in an often disorientated world. I would be grateful for prayers for all the Bishops of Scotland.”     ENDS     Peter KearneyDirectorCatholic Media Office5 St. Vincent PlaceGlasgowG1 2DH0141 221 116807968 122291pk@scmo.orgwww.scmo.org     Note to editors:   1. Images of the new office bearers are available here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/139632090@N07/albums/72157666531058155     2. Biography: Bishop Hugh Gilbert     Born in Emsworth, Hampshire, 15thMarch 1952; baptised ‘Edward’ in the Church of England; received into the Roman Catholic Church, 1970; educated at St Paul’s School, London, and King’s College, University of London (B.A. Hons, 1974); entered Pluscarden Abbey 1974, receiving the name Hugh; final profession, 10thMarch 1979; theological studies, Fort Augustus, 1977-82; ordained priest, 29thJune 1982; Novice Master 1985-2004; Prior 1990-92; Abbot 1992-2011. Nominated bishop of Aberdeen, 4thJune 2011, and ordained by Cardinal Keith O’Brien, at Aberdeen, 15thAugust 2011....

Scots Bishops thank Pope for his support

| 27th September 2018 | Blogging

27 September 2018     Scotland’s eight Catholic Bishops met Pope Francis in the Vatican this morning ( 27 September 2018) at the beginning of their Ad Limina (five-yearly) visit to Rome and thanked him for his support and prayers. After saying Mass at the tomb of St. Peter in St. Peter’s Basilica, the Bishops met Pope Francis for a 1 hour 40 minute private audience. Speaking after the audience, the President of the Bishops’ Conference, Archbishop Philip Tartaglia said;     “Our meeting with the Pope lasted almost two hours and left all the Bishops grateful to him for his fraternal and fatherly support. He encouraged us to share our experiences as pastors and leaders and took a close interest in all that we had to say.”     “The Bishops introduced a wide range of topics which we were able to discuss at length. We updated the Pope on the ecumenical work being done in Scotland to ensure that friendship, prayer and common witness among Christians will grow and flourish and he encouraged us in that work.”     “We also discussed Nuclear Disarmament and explained that the issue of Nuclear weapons had a special relevance in Scotland and was of particular concern to the church. I was able to present Pope Francis with a copy of “In God’s Image” the Church’s new Safeguarding document and the culmination of two years’ work designed to create a robust set of safeguarding procedures and protocols. The Pope thanked us for this work and urged us to continue with it.”     “Pope Francis encouraged us all in our vocations and reminded us that as bishops, we must be; close to God, close to our priests and close to our people. All of the bishops found his words uplifting and affirming and in thanking him we assured him of our prayers that he may bear the heavy responsibility which rests on his shoulders.”     After the private audience, the Bishop of Paisley, Bishop John Keenan presented Pope Francis with “Mungo” the Prayer Bear of St. Charles’ Primary School in Paisley - see photo - https://www.flickr.com/photos/139632090@N07/44035549845/       The Bishops and the Scottish students studying for the priesthood in Rome are being followed by a film crew from Solus Productions who are making a documentary on the Scots College in Rome for the BBC. Solus Producer Jim Webster said;     “Filming the Scots Bishops and students has given a fascinating insight into the inner workings of the Catholic church at the highest level. We’ve been honoured to have such privileged access to St. Peter’s Basilica and the Vatican and we are acutely conscious that this is the first time an ‘Ad Limina’ visit has ever been filmed.”     Jim Webster added;     “Apart from the sense of scale and occasion, we’ve been struck by the human stories of the students themselves. We were able to film one student as he took a bottle of whisky in to the Papal audience as a gift for the Pope, after the Pope told the students who’d served Mass for him last year, that he loved Scotch whisky.”     ENDS     Peter Kearney Director Catholic Media Office 5 St. Vincent Place Glasgow G1 2DH 0141 221 1168 07968 122291 pk@scmo.org www.scmo.org Note to Editors: The Ad Limina visit required by church law, obliges the Bishops of each country to travel to Rome, meet the Pope and in acknowledging his universal jurisdiction, make a report to him of the state of each diocese in Scotland. The following members of the Bishops' Conference will travel to Rome from 26 September until 4 October: Archbishop Philip Tartaglia, President of the Bishops' Conference of Scotland and Archbishop of Glasgow, Archbishop Leo Cushley, Archbishop of St. Andrews and Edinburgh, Bishop John Keenan, Bishop of Paisley, Bishop Joseph Toal, Bishop of Motherwell, Bishop Stephen Robson, Bishop of Dunkeld, Bishop Brian McGee, Bishop of Argyll and the Isles, Bishop Hugh Gilbert, Bishop of Aberd...